Page 91
“I’m sorry I left,” I whispered, biting the inside of my cheek to try and suppress another round of tears. “I . . .” I trailed off as my voice broke.
I couldn’t say another word because I knew if I did, I’d just cry. And if I cried, I probably wouldn’t be able to stop.
“I’m not upset,” Cohen reassured, scooting closer so he could rest a hand on my ankle, his thumb tracing small circles on the sliver of exposed skin below my leggings. “I’m just worried, Win. I want to help, but I’m not a mind reader. So I need you to talk to me. Tell me what’s going on.”
“You can’t fix this,” I snapped, wincing at how harsh my words sounded. “Wait, I’m sorry. I didn’t mean it like that.”
“I get what you’re saying,” he said softly, unmoved by my comment. “And I’m not looking to fix you, sugar. That’s not my job. But I can come alongside you so you don’t feel so alone, and point you to the only One who can help.”
I sat with those words, a small shiver wracking my body. Was it the tumultuous sea of emotions crashing inside of me or September’s evening chill? I wasn’t sure.
Without prompting, Cohen reached over to his pack and pulled out a faded navy hoodie, holding it out to me. I pressed my lips together, the small act of thoughtfulness almost the one to send me over the edge. He knew it was my favorite of his closet that I liked to steal. It always smelled like him—a blend of fresh soap, pine, and coffee. The words along the sleeve were cracked from years of wear, but they were still clear as day: “that others may live.”
I unashamedly stuck my nose in it and inhaled, my eyes fluttering shut. Cohen chuckled as I tugged it over my head, but when the torn skin of my palms caught on the sleeves, a whimper tore from my lips before I could stop myself.
“What was that?” Cohen asked calmly, helping me finish pulling it over my head and gently pulling my hair out from beneath the collar. “Are you hurt?”
“I’m fine.”
“You’ve been using that word a lot lately. Fine,” he muttered.
His eyes swept over me from head-to-toe, catching on my cheeks, and then my hands, and my knees. I finally spared a glance down at my legs for the first time, and I grimaced, quickly looking away.
So maybe “fine” wasn’t the right word.
“You fall?” he asked as he rummaged through his pack and took out a first-aid kit.
“Mm-hm.”
“Did you hit your head at all?”
“No.” I chanced a glance at him. His brow was furrowed as he gently took my hands in his own, assessing in that methodical way of his—the way that made me feel too seen.
He spent the next few minutes tending to my scrapes, not a word spoken. When he moved to my knees though, tugging up the bottom of my leggings to expose my bloody shins and knees, my vision blurred.
“Eyes here.” Cohen’s voice pierced through the fog as he gently grasped my chin, tapping my jaw with his index finger.
My attention snapped to him, and everything in my head quieted. He exuded an easy confidence that made the fear retreat, if only for a moment.
“Breathe,” he murmured, nodding when I sucked in a shaky breath and slowly let it out. “Good. Keep those eyes on me, sugar. I’ll get you cleaned up.”
I watched his expressions as he tended to my legs with practiced skill. Every tender touch and intentional ministration of care only centered me further, only drove home what I already knew in my heart.
I loved him—like, loved him with a love that felt so big it was terrifying. I loved his kind smile and nerdy humor. I loved the way he took care of everyone around him. I loved his persistent optimism. And I loved how he trusted God with a faith that made me ache to have the same depth of relationship with the Lord. It felt so far from my reach, though.
“You have some blood on your face,” Cohen informed softly, his fingers gently turning my head as he cleaned my cheek. And then he gently nudged my chin up, leaning in to press a kiss to my forehead before pulling back, his hand falling away. I immediately missed the contact, almost reaching out to grab his hand, but I stopped myself, my fingers knotting together in my lap.
I had fallen so hard for Cohen. God had given me everything and more that I had asked for, and I couldn’t imagine my life without him now. My days were filled with a man who cared for me in a way that showcased Christlike love, and here I was spiraling when things were better than they’d ever been.
Sure. Everything is great now, but what happens when God takes him from me too?
The thought sat heavy with me. I knew that wasn’t true—at least I thought I did—yet it kept bubbling up to the surface no matter how many times I tried to dismiss it.
“What was that thought?” Cohen asked, and I reflexively shook my head.
“Nothing. I’m fine.”
And then there were his hands, calloused and familiar, gently bracketing either side of my face and tilting it so I was forced to look at him.