AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Baked with Love

Page 92

by Ariana Kemp

“We’re not doing that,” he murmured tenderly, though there was an uncompromising edge to his tone that I had never heard from him before. “We’re getting everything out in the open so we can move forward. You’ve bottled up whatever this is for months, sugar. No more. Now, what was that thought?”

My mouth opened and closed, and I tried, I tried to make my lips form the words, but the fear was suffocating. My eyes pricked with tears, and I wanted so badly to pull away. I felt too seen. Too raw, like a live wire. But his hands were there, forcing me to keep his gaze.

“I’m fine.” I tried to maintain my carefully crafted front, but both Cohen and I knew it was a façade.

“Do it scared, pretty girl.” His words were a mere exhale, almost carried away by the breeze, and I tried to swallow the lump in my throat.

“What if God takes you too?” I almost didn’t recognize my voice as my hands came up to grasp his wrists. “He’s taken nearly everyone I love. What if he takes you too, Cohen?”

The words tasted acrid as I said them. Shame and relief tore at either side of me, warring. I had said them. I had given voice to the fear that had been plaguing me for months, making it real.

And though Cohen was blurry through my tears, I could make out his features softening as he hummed sympathetically, so much understanding and kindness there. His thumbs gently brushed away a few of the rogue tears that had spilled onto my cheeks.

“I know that sounds horrible. I know.” I couldn’t stop the word vomit if I tried. “I know He’s a good Father and He wants good things for me, and I tell myself that over and over. When I’m with you, I am happier than I think I’ve ever been. I feel seen and safe and supported, and you’re so steady. I have craved steadiness my entire life—since I was a little girl, and you give me that.”

I paused, blinking rapidly and looking up to try and avoid his gaze, but I couldn’t, his eyes trained on me with gentle insistence. He didn’t say a word, waiting for me to continue.

“But as soon as it’s quiet, as soon as I’m alone, Cohen, I feel like I can’t breathe. The fear is literally suffocating me. I don’t think I can take losing you,” I continued, clutching his wrists even tighter, my knuckles blanching. “I feel like I’m always waiting for the other shoe to drop, and I’m so tired.”

I let out a teary, mirthless laugh, my chin quivering as I tried to get these last words out without devolving into sobs.

“Which feels crazy because this is the happiest I think I’ve ever been. I should be basking in it. God gave me more than I could have ever asked for. He answered my prayer. He heard me,” I whimpered, hiccuping on my words. “I don’t know what to do anymore. I love you with every fiber of my being, and I can’t even begin to think of losing you. It’s terrifying.” I swallowed thickly. “But being with you scares me just as much, and I don’t know how to make that fear go away, so I’m just . . . just drowning. I don’t want to be scared anymore, but I don’t know how to do that. I’ve tried, Cohen, I swear, I’ve tried⁠—”

My voice broke as a strangled sob tore from my lips.

“Aw, Win.” Cohen’s hand slid to the back of my neck and he tugged me to his chest, his other arm circling around me and holding me tight to him, the whisper of his lips pressing against the crown of my head.

We sat there for what seemed like forever, me clinging to him as wave after wave of tears washed over me. He just held me close, murmuring soft reassurances against my temple and letting me cry. By the time the tears slowed, his shirt was damp and I was exhausted. I pulled back a little, sniffling, and Cohen reached over to his pack and grabbed the little pack of tissues he always kept in the side. I was too tired to even care as I wiped my eyes and blew my nose, feeling at least a shred more human, and a whole lot more embarrassed.

“I’m so sorry. That was a lot,” I laughed nervously, looking anywhere but Cohen.

“That was a lot to be carrying all on your own,” Cohen amended my statement, those hands finding what felt like their home on either side of my face, guiding me to look at him yet again.

I stared at the hollow of his throat, the thought of looking into his eyes almost too much to bear after I had laid everything out like that. I had told him what I didn’t even want to voice to myself.

“Win, look at me,” he prodded softly. “Please.”

The please is what did me in. I slowly met his gaze, scared of what I would find, but there was only compassion there, so much compassion that my eyes pricked with tears again.

“I love you,” he murmured. “I thank God for you every day. For your kindness, your selflessness, your love of nature.” My heart swelled at the words. “I want to grow old and gray with you, Winifred Hayes, and I hope and pray we get to do that with one another.”

His tongue darted out and wet his lips as he searched for his next words.

“But even if we don’t, even if God calls you or me home tomorrow, He is still good,” he said firmly, and I tried to pull away, but he only held me tighter. “No. Listen to me, Winifred. I understand your fear, and I feel it too. I can’t even stomach the thought of losing you. It would destroy me, baby.”

“You’re scared too?”

“Yes, because you are so precious to me, I can’t even fathom having to live a single day without you by my side.” He gave me a gentle shake. “And what a blessing it is to have been given someone I love so much that I’m scared to lose them. The Lord gave and the Lord has taken away; may the name of the Lord be praised.”

I sniffled, reaching up to grasp his wrists once again, anchoring myself.

“Winifred, we live in a cursed world. You’ve already known so much hurt, sugar, and I wish I could shield you from all of it, but I can’t,” he murmured. “I can tell you with full faith though, that the very Creator of this universe loves you and promises to walk alongside you.”

He swiped at a stray tear before he dipped his head closer to rest his forehead on mine, thumbs gently brushing across my cheekbones.

“I think you already know that, but fear has a way of turning everything around up here.” He lightly tapped my temple. “God has not given you a spirit of fear, Winnie, but of power, and love, and self-control. I just think you need a little reminder of that.”

“I don’t remember how to trust Him,” I admitted, words coming a bit easier now that the knot in my chest had started to loosen. “I’ve been sitting in this fear for so long, I don’t know how to stop being scared.”